| # | name | location(s) |
| 0 | a sad-eyed beagle plushie | ? |
| 1 | a velvety Lady Saresyn plushie | ? |
| 2 | a fuzzywuzzy cow plushie | ? |
| 3 | a squeaky field mouse plushie | ? |
| 4 | an animated mushroofalo plushie | ? |
| 5 | a sparkly King Sandoval plushie | ? |
| 6 | a feathery swan plushie | Tower of Art, daily reward, HB (FP entrance) |
| 7 | a puffy emperor penguin plushie | Xaventry, daily reward |
| 8 | a soft bunny rabbit plushie | ? |
| 9 | a sweet heart-shaped plushie | ? |
| 10 | a soft kitty plushie | ? |
| 11 | a smiling Brother Rufus plushie | Sigil |
| 12 | a star-speckled Balthazar plushie | Rune, daily reward |
| 13 | a laughing walrus plushie | Decara |
| 14 | a cackling Baba Yaga plushie | Unseelie |
| 15 | a singing Perlin Noise plushie | ? |
| 16 | a playful pony plushie | ? |
| 17 | an elegant Lady Telleri plushie | ? |
| 18 | a regal Lord Agrippa plushie | Tower of Art |
| 19 | a beautiful butterfly plushie | Arcane, Winton, daily reward |
| 20 | a huggable caterpillar plushie | ? |
| 21 | a goofy-looking wiener dog plushie | ? |
| 22 | a sensually soft Pynai plushie | ? |
| 23 | a glowering Ghryzhrymydyon plushie | Sigil, daily reward |
| 24 | a fiery Vyst plushie | daily reward |
| 25 | a bloody Prince Galzmati plushie | ? |
| 26 | a pretty Princess Paenyr plushie | Rahdiyr |
| 27 | a miniscule kitten plushie | ? |
| 28 | a fluffy sheep plushie | ? |
| 29 | a floppy-eared puppy plushie | ? |